Broker of Record Letters are NOT the Devil, Shoptalk Series – Episode #17

Podcast » Broker of Record Letters are NOT the Devil, Shoptalk Series – Episode #17

In this episode of The Power Producers Podcast, David Carothers and co-host Kyle Houck talk about the Broker of Record letter, how it can be utilized as a tool in the industry, and why a lot of people see it as a devil in the insurance industry.

Episode Highlights:

David mentions that he loves the broker of records, but a lot of people don’t. (5:38)
Kyle mentions that the broker of records letter is a wonderful topic. (5:43)
David explains why people don’t like it. (5:49)
David shares that a small percentage of agents and agencies are a little bit sly with how they present a BOR. (6:15)
David mentions that the BOR is a tool that was developed by their industry. (7:33)
David shares that he doesn’t understand why an agent should think that they can do a poor job, or deliver average results and retain an account. (8:08)
David shares a fun fact. (8:36)
David shares that the reason why agents get upset is that they don’t realize, they’re inadequate in what they’re delivering. (10:09)
David mentions that in this period, you have to understand that you can’t be a salesperson and retain your accounts. (10:45)
Kyle mentions that customer service is expected. (11:34)
David shares that from a claim standpoint, they’re managing the loss ratio in their book of business with the carrier because they want to make sure they get their own profit-sharing and contingencies, at the end of the year. (12:42)
David gives an example of a man that was complaining about a longtime account that started with him. (12:59)
David mentions that the cheapest insurance policy is typically the most expensive, in the long run. (15:10)
David shares that you cannot tie your compensation to the sale of a product, you are not a trusted adviser in that role. You are a salesman or a saleswoman, in that role. (15:32)
David mentions that if you don’t want to lose your business, work to keep it. (19:13)
David shares that simply because you’re doing the work that needs to be done to improve premium losses, doesn’t mean your client knows you’re doing that. (22:06)
David mentions that if you can’t provide graphics or something that they can touch and feel in real-time, your account could be in jeopardy, all the time. (22:36)

Tweetable Quotes:

“What I’m talking about is the whole actual tool of the agent of record or broker of record letter, and that in and of itself is not bad. It is not sleazy and it is not slimy. It is a tool that was developed by our industry. So that the client can pick the agent that they want.” – David Carothers
“The agencies that are using the BOR and AOR the correct way, are operating well within the framework of what the industry gives us, and we’re not hiding behind it. I’ve never taken an ASR and slipped it into a stack of papers, and just had somebody sign it.” – David Carothers
“It’s like I tell my kids don’t lie to me. I’m gonna get you eventually. Then I go back and remember when I asked you to be honest with me, and you weren’t. There are far fewer consequences if you’re honest with me, on the front end.” – David Carothers
“People, value is not a cheap premium. Cheap premium is great, but if you have uncovered things because the premium is cheap, then guess what, it’s either your E&O or out of your client’s pocket, but then it’s added to the total cost of risk.” – David Carothers
“You can only go so low on the premiums, you can only get so many discounts and multi-line, or whatsoever. I mean, once you’re on the floor, you’re on the floor. If that’s all you’re going in with and you have no value then, of course, you’re going to get that swipe.” – Kyle Houck
“The problem is insurance salespeople, agency owners that focus on selling insurance and not delivering value, have to understand that it’s not smoke and mirrors, people. That’s a value proposition.” – David Carothers
“Everybody else out there, brokers of record letters, are not the devil. Quit selling insurance and start delivering value. Quit doing customer service and start offering an awesome client experience. That’s it. It’s not rocket science, you just got to get off your rear end and do a little something, once the deal is done.” – David Carothers

Resources Mentioned:

Available On

David Carothers

Kyle Houck

From Policies to Profitability: How Strategic Risk Consulting Can Transform Middle Market Insurance Production – A Conversation with Doug Benz

July 3, 2025

Middle market producers often believe that bigger accounts come from quoting better, faster, or cheaper. But in reality, the leap from writing $5,000 policies to closing $1.2 million in premium starts with a different mindset. It starts with consulting over quoting. That’s exactly the story that unfolded at Producers in Paradise when Doug Benz shared how he landed the largest account of his career—not by selling insurance, but by solving problems no one else could.

This post breaks down the step-by-step strategy Doug and his mentor David Carothers used to win a high-stakes, complex account through total cost of risk analysis, claims data visibility, and certificate compliance solutions. If you’re a commercial producer trying to break into the middle market, this blueprint is for you.

From InsurTech to Relationship-Driven Risk Management: Lessons for Modern Insurance Producers – A Conversation with Brett Fulmer

June 27, 2025

In a constantly evolving insurance landscape, commercial producers are being forced to adapt—quickly. Between InsurTech advancements, shifting market conditions, and increasing client expectations, producers must learn how to balance innovation with deep relationship-building and technical risk expertise. On a recent episode of the Power Producers Podcast, industry veteran David Carothers sat down with Brett Fulmer, principal at Newport Beach Insurance Center, to talk about navigating these dynamics with authenticity and strategy. What followed was a roadmap for producers who want to succeed in today’s middle market.

How Successful Insurance Producers Can Stay Grounded, Build Respect, and Avoid the Arrogance Trap

June 26, 2025

In the commercial insurance industry, success can come fast—especially for driven producers who are focused on the middle market. The money starts coming in, the book grows, and you find yourself standing in rooms where you once only dreamed of being. But with that success comes a subtle trap—one that’s caught more than a few top producers off guard: arrogance.

It’s not always loud or obvious. Sometimes, it’s the silent erosion of empathy. Other times, it’s the misplaced belief that your way is the only way. In this post, I want to explore how insurance producers can stay grounded even as their careers take off, how they can build respect by honoring where they came from, and how to avoid becoming the very kind of producer people whisper about after conferences for all the wrong reasons.

The Hidden Cost of Misclassification: Mastering Workers’ Comp Class Codes for Middle Market Success

June 18, 2025

In the world of commercial insurance, no phrase inspires more dread—or confusion—than “workers’ comp audit.” Often, the root cause of these audits isn’t fraud or underreporting, but something far more preventable: incorrect workers’ compensation class codes.

Mastering B2B Email Marketing: How to Write Subject Lines That Convert and Click-Through Strategies That Drive Results – A Conversation with Jay Schwedelson

June 17, 2025

If you’re in commercial insurance sales or B2B marketing, chances are you’ve dabbled in email outreach. And if you’re like most, you’ve probably concluded that email doesn’t work anymore. But what if the problem isn’t the channel—it’s the way you’re using it?

Unlocking Profitability: Why Leading with Workers’ Compensation Is the Smartest Move for Commercial Producers – A Conversation with Kevin Ring

June 11, 2025

In a hard market defined by razor-thin margins, rising premiums, and fierce competition, commercial insurance producers are constantly looking for ways to stand out. One of the most overlooked—and yet most powerful—strategies is to lead with workers’ compensation insurance.