In this episode of Power Producer Shop Talk, host David Carothers delivers a masterclass on navigating the shift from a hard to a soft market, emphasizing that the time to prepare is now. With reinsurance renewals signaling a softening, David warns that the easy “price shopping” wins of the hard market are disappearing, and producers must pivot to value-based selling to displace incumbents who are now delivering good news (rate decreases).
David also breaks down the Total Cost of Risk (TCOR) conversation, explaining why it is the ultimate differentiator for accounts in the $100k-$250k premium range. He details how to uncover “hidden” costs like active vs. passive retained losses and why many businesses are overpaying by acting as their own insurance company without getting the credit for it.
David explains that while the message remains consistent, the delivery must change as we move from a hard market (where incumbents deliver bad news) to a soft market (where they deliver rate decreases). Producers must “sew their seeds” now by cleaning up accounts and focusing on Total Cost of Risk to lock in clients before the next hard cycle hits.
For producers intimidated by financial jargon, David simplifies TCOR. It’s not just premium—it’s the sum of insurance costs, retained losses, and risk management expenses. He explains that using the word “cost” instead of “price” or “premium” instantly elevates the conversation and positions you as a strategic partner rather than a vendor.
David dives into the nuance of retained losses. An active retained loss is a conscious decision (e.g., a high deductible or choosing not to buy cyber coverage). A passive retained loss is an unexpected hit (e.g., an uncovered claim due to an exclusion). He shares a story of a contractor paying all claims under $5k out of pocket without getting any deductible credit—a massive opportunity for a savvy producer to step in and structure a proper program.
David shares a personal example of how he handles Department of Defense (DoD) contractors. Since he lacks the security clearance to inspect classified manufacturing areas, he uses a service called Yellowbird to hire ex-military professionals with active clearances to perform the loss control inspections. This creative problem-solving eliminates a major barrier to entry that stops most competitors in their tracks.
While TCOR works for larger accounts, David argues that the $100k-$250k premium space is the “fertile ground” where this conversation is most effective. These businesses are often large enough to have complex risks but small enough that they haven’t been introduced to sophisticated risk management concepts by their current broker.
The commercial insurance world isn’t for the faint of heart. It’s unpredictable, chaotic, and constantly demanding producers to manage competing pressures—client needs, renewal deadlines, life events, prospecting goals, and agency responsibilities. And if you’re a middle-market producer, multiply that by ten.
In the middle market commercial insurance space, the role of the producer has never been more critical—or more misunderstood. Too many producers still view their job as selling policies instead of what it truly is: protecting the assets and livelihoods of the businesses they serve.
The middle market rewards depth, not breadth. Yet many producers still approach it like a volume game, quoting everything that moves, chasing price, and hoping activity turns into production. From the outside, it looks like hustle. From the inside of the underwriting and wholesale world, it looks like noise.
Personal lines has quietly become one of the most competitive segments in the insurance industry. Agencies that once dominated their local markets are now fighting to differentiate themselves against direct writers, digital-first carriers, and large brokers with massive content machines.
The cyber insurance market has always been unpredictable. Over the past decade, we’ve seen it move from an emerging line of coverage to one of the most volatile, swinging rapidly between soft and hard market cycles. But today, cyber has entered one of the softest markets in recent memory—and that presents a rare opportunity for both agents and clients.
For most of my 20-year career, captives felt like something reserved for the insurance elite—the jumbo accounts, the Fortune-level operations, the companies with multimillion-dollar manual premiums and entire departments dedicated to risk management. If you had asked me ten or fifteen years ago whether a $250,000 account was a legitimate captive candidate, I would’ve laughed. I thought captives were reserved for companies so complex and so large that the only rational way to insure them was to build an insurance company around their risk.
Please confirm you want to block this member.
You will no longer be able to:
Please note: This action will also remove this member from your connections and send a report to the site admin. Please allow a few minutes for this process to complete.
