Bridging the Insurance Talent Gap: Culture, Compensation, and Career Growth in a Changing Industry – A Conversation with Tony Canas

The insurance industry is undergoing a generational shift that can no longer be ignored. Between the rise of InsurTech, the acceleration of remote work, and the growing demand for equity in agency culture and compensation, the traditional model of how agencies attract, retain, and grow talent is crumbling. In a recent episode of the Power Producers Podcast, we spoke with Tony Canas—Chief Motivational Officer of Insurance Nerds and founder of Top Hat Recruiting—about the big challenges facing our workforce and what leaders need to do to evolve.

This conversation was packed with insight from both the agency and carrier side, and it highlighted just how important it is to bridge the communication gap between producers, account managers, and leadership in today’s insurance ecosystem.

Understanding the Divide Between Sales and Service Teams

One of the most common and unfortunate dynamics in insurance agencies is the perceived “house divided” between producers and account managers. This rift often stems from a lack of operational understanding. Producers may view account managers as support staff, while account managers may feel undervalued despite being the glue that holds the book of business together.

What many agencies miss is that bridging this divide starts with empathy and education. Producers must learn how service roles function—not necessarily to perform them, but to better support, communicate with, and appreciate the team that helps them succeed. As Tony Canas pointed out, this principle applies across the entire industry: “The more we understand what the other roles do, the more we can get people in the right seat on the bus.”

Culture is More Than Pizza Fridays: What Modern Insurance Talent Actually Wants

Agency owners love to say they have a “great company culture,” but often that’s just code for free snacks or casual Fridays. In today’s environment, insurance professionals want more than surface-level perks. They want purpose, flexibility, and the opportunity to grow.

Canas highlighted a small Texas agency that punches above its weight by building culture around gratitude and flexibility. Despite having a limited budget, their remote-friendly, value-driven approach made them incredibly attractive to talent. This proves that you don’t need Google-sized resources to create a winning culture—you need intention and consistency.

True culture isn’t created in ping-pong rooms; it’s created in how leadership shows up for their people.

Producer Compensation vs. Account Manager Recognition

There’s no question that producers often carry the weight of agency growth. But what about the people who help those accounts renew, service the book, and manage client relationships long after the sale?

Too often, account managers are sidelined in the compensation conversation. Producers receive golden handcuffs—equity, bonuses, and perks—while service staff are told to be grateful for a Friday pizza party. But as David Carothers points out, “If you’re building wealth as a producer through recurring revenue, what about the people who keep that revenue from walking out the door?”

Some ESOP agencies have flipped this model, giving every team member—from the receptionist to the senior account executive—a stake in the agency. Not only does this align everyone’s incentives, but it also builds stronger relationships, loyalty, and performance.

Career Paths for Account Managers: The Silent Crisis

The industry is facing a demographic and educational shift. The high school-educated, ultra-loyal account manager who stayed for 30 years is becoming increasingly rare. The next generation of women—the backbone of most service teams—are now more educated than ever. In fact, nearly 60% of all college degrees today go to women, and they’re looking for careers, not just jobs.

The problem? Most agencies offer no clear career path for account managers beyond “do the same thing for more years.” This is driving top performers to leave the industry—or at least their current agency—in search of growth opportunities.

As Tony explained, “Unless we create a defined path to grow that doesn’t require becoming a producer, we’re going to lose some of the best service talent we have.”

Diversity, Inclusion, and Equity: From Talk to Transformation

The insurance industry has made progress, but it still struggles with meaningful diversity, equity, and inclusion. Many leadership teams are still dominated by older white men, while the service side is disproportionately female. Meanwhile, the barriers to career advancement for minorities, women, and professionals with disabilities are real—and often ignored.

Tony shared the story of his girlfriend, a highly successful executive who uses a wheelchair. Her rise in the industry happened in large part because she was able to work remotely, where her performance spoke louder than any visual bias.

When done right, remote work can be an equalizer that opens doors for top talent who may not otherwise have had the same opportunities. But it requires intention, not just policy.

The Remote Work Revolution: Threat or Opportunity?

COVID-19 didn’t just change where we work—it changed how we think about work altogether. Remote flexibility is no longer a luxury; it’s a strategic advantage in the talent war.

If you’re a small agency in the Midwest, you may be tempted to cling to traditional hiring practices. But make no mistake: the biggest brokerages in New York, LA, and Chicago are already hiring your best people remotely, offering more money than they could ever get locally, while still saving on urban salaries and overhead.

For agencies that want to stay competitive, the blueprint is simple:

Embrace flexible work arrangements
Level the playing field for all employees
Create a culture that values outcomes over office attendance

There’s no putting the genie back in the bottle—and that’s a good thing.

The Role of Curiosity and Empathy in Building a Modern Agency

Tony and David both agreed on one trait that defines exceptional leadership and sales performance: curiosity. Great producers aren’t just great closers—they’re great question-askers. They care enough to understand the people around them.

David put it best: “If you’re doing your job, you don’t have to ask people what motivates them—you already know.”

This same principle applies to team building. Leaders should understand their employees’ professional goals, personal motivators, and communication styles. Do they prefer recognition in public or in private? Do they want career development or work-life balance?

When you slow down long enough to get to know your people, you earn the loyalty that can’t be bought.

Branding with Personality: How Magic Became a Marketing Tool

You might not expect to hear about magic tricks in a conversation about insurance recruiting, but for Tony Canas, being a magician is part of his brand—and that’s exactly the point.

By wearing a top hat and performing magic at conferences, Tony creates memorable moments that build connection and curiosity. It’s not just flair; it’s strategic differentiation in an industry where everyone tends to look the same.

Your agency doesn’t need a magician. But it does need personality. Whether you’re building a producer brand or a recruiting presence, memorability matters. And in a world of Zoom calls and LinkedIn posts, being different is your competitive edge.

Final Thoughts: What the Insurance Industry Must Embrace to Thrive

The biggest takeaway from this conversation is clear: the future of insurance belongs to the agencies and carriers that are willing to do the hard work of change. That means:

Rethinking career development beyond producers
Building inclusive and diverse cultures
Adopting remote work as a talent magnet
Investing in internal relationships with the same fervor we show prospects

The agencies that win will be those who understand that building culture and team loyalty isn’t just good HR—it’s smart business.

If you want to retain your best people, attract new talent, and create a legacy that outlasts market cycles, then it’s time to stop managing by habit and start leading with intention.

Maximizing Middle-Market Workers’ Compensation Success: Data-Driven Prospecting, Compliance Wedges, and Claims Excellence

July 31, 2025 No Comments

Middle-mazrket businesses face unique challenges when it comes to managing their workers’ compensation programs. Unlike large enterprises, they often lack dedicated in-house resources for safety, compliance, and claims oversight; yet unlike small businesses, their scale subjects them to more sophisticated regulatory scrutiny and larger potential losses. In this environment, commercial insurance producers who master an integrated approach—combining precise prospecting data, impactful compliance applications, and exceptional claims handling—can both win new accounts and build lasting client relationships.

Strategic Market Access for Independent Agencies: Unlocking Growth, Stability, and Profitability

July 31, 2025 No Comments

In the most challenging insurance market many of us have ever seen, independent agencies are grappling with a familiar foe: limited carrier access. Whether you’re a former captive agent trying to break into the independent space or a small agency trying to grow your commercial book, the obstacles are real. Direct appointments are hard to come by, especially for shops under $5 million in revenue, and wholesale markets can feel intimidating or like a last resort.

But they don’t have to be. With the right partner, wholesale and brokerage relationships can become a strategic advantage, not just a stopgap. This post explores how agencies can leverage smart market access to grow confidently, preserve profitability, and position themselves for long-term success.

Building High-Performing Remote Insurance Teams: Core Values, Hiring, Onboarding & KPI Strategies

July 30, 2025 No Comments

The insurance industry is undergoing a profound transformation as middle-market agencies recognize the benefits and challenges of embracing a fully remote workforce. No longer viewed as a temporary workaround, remote models offer the potential to tap into nationwide and offshore talent pools, reduce overhead, and increase flexibility in an increasingly digital world. Yet, flipping the switch to virtual operations can expose gaps in documentation, dilute corporate culture, and strain traditional oversight mechanisms. In this post, we’ll explore the four pillars essential to building a high-performing remote insurance team—core values, hiring practices, onboarding processes, and KPI strategies—while also delving into best practices for managing domestic versus offshore employees, ensuring data security, leveraging productivity tools, and fostering trust and autonomy.

Captive Insurance Strategies for Middle Market Success: Empowering Independent Agents with Risk Control and Profitability

July 28, 2025 No Comments

In today’s hard commercial insurance market, middle market business owners are more open than ever to solutions that give them greater control over their insurance costs. While guaranteed cost programs remain the default option, they often lack the flexibility and long-term savings that high-performing businesses crave. That’s where captive insurance comes in—a powerful but often misunderstood tool that enables clients to turn insurance from a sunk cost into a strategic asset.

Streamlining Agency Billing and Premium Financing: Leveraging FedNow, 3-D Secure, and Integrated AMS for Faster Funding

July 16, 2025 No Comments

Middle-market insurance agencies have long wrestled with the legacy “buy-bill-collect” model, in which carriers invoice agencies, agencies collect premiums from clients, and only then remit payment to carriers. This antiquated workflow creates operational friction, delayed cash flow, and elevated chargeback risks—all of which can erode profitability and client satisfaction. Today, however, powerful innovations in digital payments and agency management systems are enabling a modern “bill-collect-buy” paradigm that dramatically accelerates fund availability, minimizes disputes, and unlocks new revenue streams through premium financing.

Why Most Salespeople Fail: Mastering the Mindset, Process, and Power Dynamics of Professional Selling

July 8, 2025 No Comments

The truth about professional sales isn’t flashy, and it certainly isn’t about charisma. If you think selling is about having the “gift of gab,” winging it on calls, or leaning on your likability to win deals, you’re doing it wrong—and that’s why you’re struggling. In this post, we’re breaking down lessons from a brutally honest conversation with Benjamin Dennehy, the UK’s Most Hated Sales Trainer®, about why so many producers in commercial insurance and other industries fall short—and what the top performers do differently.