Cracking the Code on Producer Compensation and Equity: Building Scalable, Profitable Insurance Agencies – A Conversation with Colby Allen

When it comes to building a successful commercial insurance agency, few topics are as polarizing—or as poorly understood—as producer compensation and equity. Whether you’re recruiting new producers or trying to retain the rainmakers already on your team, how you handle compensation can either fuel your growth or frustrate it.

But it’s not just about percentages on new and renewal business. If you want to build a scalable, profitable insurance agency, you need to take a strategic, data-informed approach that balances margin, performance, and long-term value creation. This article unpacks what top-performing agencies are doing to get it right—and what you should be thinking about if you’re ready to level up.

The Producer Compensation Dilemma

Why do so many agencies fail to retain top talent? It often starts with how they compensate producers—and more importantly, how they structure support around that compensation.

“Every agency wants a killer producer, but very few are actually structured to make them successful.” – David Carothers

Too many agencies are still operating on legacy models: they look for producers with a Rolodex, throw them a draw or a split, and hope for the best. There’s no training program. No accountability. No clarity on what success looks like.

This problem is magnified when agencies try to scale without clear validation timelines or realistic expectations. As a result, many new producers crash and burn within 12–18 months, and agency owners are left wondering what went wrong.

Designing a Compensation Model That Works

If you’re building your producer compensation model starting with percentages, you’re doing it backward. According to Colby Allen, VP of Agency Consulting at Agency Brokerage Consultants, the best-performing agencies treat compensation as the final step in a broader planning process.

“Most agencies focus on the percentage without understanding their service and sales models. That’s where they go wrong.” – Colby Allen

Here’s the right approach:

Start with your target profit margin.
Define your sales and service model.
Calculate your overhead and support costs.
Back into the commission splits based on what’s sustainable.

This “budget-first” approach ensures that you’re building a model that not only incentivizes producers but also protects agency margins and sets clear expectations.

Why New vs. Renewal Splits Matter

New business is risky and time-intensive. Renewal business is (hopefully) easier to maintain but requires service and retention work. That’s why most agencies adopt different commission splits for each.

Well-supported agencies might pay producers 40% new and 25% renewal, while high-commission shops might offer 70/50 but expect producers to service their own books. Both can work—but only if they align with the actual role and support structure.

Compensation Structures in Action

Across the industry, you’ll see a wide variety of compensation structures:

Straight Commission: Producers bet on themselves and earn high percentages—but must generate their own leads and manage their own books.
Base + Commission: Often used with newer producers; provides stability while they ramp up.
Stair-Step Models: Gradual reduction in base salary over time, paired with increasing commission, to transition producers into full performance mode.

“Producers don’t want guarantees—they want opportunity. And the best ones will bet on themselves.” – David Carothers

Some of the most successful agencies use stair-step models with clear validation goals over a 4-year window. For example, $4,000/month in Year 1, dropping by $1,000 each year until the producer is fully commission-based. This gives the producer a sense of security early on while motivating them to ramp quickly.

Building a Support System for Producers

It’s not enough to just offer a competitive split. If you’re not giving producers the resources to win, you’re sabotaging their success.

Tech stacks, lead gen tools, marketing support, risk management services, account management teams—all of these matter. In fact, a producer on a 40% plan with best-in-class support may be far more productive and profitable than one getting 70% and flying solo.

“If you’re paying a producer 70/50 and expecting them to service the book too, they’ll cap out fast.” – Colby Allen

Division of labor is key. Top agencies create micro-teams around producers so they can focus solely on sales. The support team handles service, coverage questions, and client retention.

Producer Retention and Long-Term Incentives

Getting producers in the door is one thing—keeping them is another. And the producers most worth retaining are also the ones most likely to leave if they don’t see a path for growth and autonomy.

“If you’ve got entrepreneurial producers but don’t reward their ambition, they’ll leave and start their own shop.” – David Carothers

Smart agencies are investing in long-term retention tools:

Supplemental Executive Retirement Plans (SERPs)
Equity in the book of business or in the agency
Buy-sell agreements with predefined exit terms

These golden handcuffs are essential if you want to retain your top 20%—because they’re likely already getting recruited by other shops.

“Treat your agency like an investment, not just a business. The ROI will follow.” – Colby Allen

Balancing Agency Profitability with Producer Pay

Here’s a surprising truth: in many agencies, producers are earning more than the owners—at least on paper. If you don’t structure compensation wisely, you can easily find yourself carrying all the risk and getting none of the reward.

The key is understanding your agency profit margin and building your comp plans accordingly. National benchmarks suggest that healthy insurance agencies target a 30% profit margin, but that number can drop quickly if your producer splits are too aggressive.

“There are easily scenarios where producers are making more than the owner. And that’s a structural problem.” – Colby Allen

Agency owners must also decide: Do you want to be income statement rich—or balance sheet rich? Squeezing margin today might feel good, but building a strong, scalable agency will pay off exponentially at perpetuation or exit.

Your Next Steps

If you’re an agency owner looking to revamp your producer compensation model, here’s where to start:

Audit your financials. Back out producer compensation and see what’s left for profit.
Map your sales and service model. Know your average account size, cost to service, and target margin.
Build your validation plan. Give new producers a realistic path with clear benchmarks.
Incorporate retention tools. Think beyond commission to SERPs, equity, and buy-sell frameworks.
Invest in support. Give your producers the tech, training, and team they need to thrive.

And if you don’t feel confident doing all of that alone—don’t. There are experienced consultants who specialize in insurance agency compensation and equity models and can help you do it right the first time.

Final Thoughts

This is a complex conversation, but it’s one worth having—openly and often. Producer compensation isn’t just about how much someone earns. It’s about how you scale, how you retain talent, and how you build enterprise value.

“You negotiate your exit on the way in—because when the emotion’s removed, the logic prevails.” – David Carothers

It’s time to stop guessing and start strategizing. Because what you build today will determine what your agency is worth tomorrow.

From Policies to Profitability: How Strategic Risk Consulting Can Transform Middle Market Insurance Production – A Conversation with Doug Benz

July 3, 2025 No Comments

Middle market producers often believe that bigger accounts come from quoting better, faster, or cheaper. But in reality, the leap from writing $5,000 policies to closing $1.2 million in premium starts with a different mindset. It starts with consulting over quoting. That’s exactly the story that unfolded at Producers in Paradise when Doug Benz shared how he landed the largest account of his career—not by selling insurance, but by solving problems no one else could.

This post breaks down the step-by-step strategy Doug and his mentor David Carothers used to win a high-stakes, complex account through total cost of risk analysis, claims data visibility, and certificate compliance solutions. If you’re a commercial producer trying to break into the middle market, this blueprint is for you.

From InsurTech to Relationship-Driven Risk Management: Lessons for Modern Insurance Producers – A Conversation with Brett Fulmer

June 27, 2025 No Comments

In a constantly evolving insurance landscape, commercial producers are being forced to adapt—quickly. Between InsurTech advancements, shifting market conditions, and increasing client expectations, producers must learn how to balance innovation with deep relationship-building and technical risk expertise. On a recent episode of the Power Producers Podcast, industry veteran David Carothers sat down with Brett Fulmer, principal at Newport Beach Insurance Center, to talk about navigating these dynamics with authenticity and strategy. What followed was a roadmap for producers who want to succeed in today’s middle market.

How Successful Insurance Producers Can Stay Grounded, Build Respect, and Avoid the Arrogance Trap

June 26, 2025 No Comments

In the commercial insurance industry, success can come fast—especially for driven producers who are focused on the middle market. The money starts coming in, the book grows, and you find yourself standing in rooms where you once only dreamed of being. But with that success comes a subtle trap—one that’s caught more than a few top producers off guard: arrogance.

It’s not always loud or obvious. Sometimes, it’s the silent erosion of empathy. Other times, it’s the misplaced belief that your way is the only way. In this post, I want to explore how insurance producers can stay grounded even as their careers take off, how they can build respect by honoring where they came from, and how to avoid becoming the very kind of producer people whisper about after conferences for all the wrong reasons.

The Hidden Cost of Misclassification: Mastering Workers’ Comp Class Codes for Middle Market Success

June 18, 2025 No Comments

In the world of commercial insurance, no phrase inspires more dread—or confusion—than “workers’ comp audit.” Often, the root cause of these audits isn’t fraud or underreporting, but something far more preventable: incorrect workers’ compensation class codes.

Mastering B2B Email Marketing: How to Write Subject Lines That Convert and Click-Through Strategies That Drive Results – A Conversation with Jay Schwedelson

June 17, 2025 No Comments

If you’re in commercial insurance sales or B2B marketing, chances are you’ve dabbled in email outreach. And if you’re like most, you’ve probably concluded that email doesn’t work anymore. But what if the problem isn’t the channel—it’s the way you’re using it?

Unlocking Profitability: Why Leading with Workers’ Compensation Is the Smartest Move for Commercial Producers – A Conversation with Kevin Ring

June 11, 2025 No Comments

In a hard market defined by razor-thin margins, rising premiums, and fierce competition, commercial insurance producers are constantly looking for ways to stand out. One of the most overlooked—and yet most powerful—strategies is to lead with workers’ compensation insurance.