Leveraging AI and Authentic Storytelling to Build Trust and Drive Sales in Commercial Insurance – A Conversation with Jim Matuga

In the ever-evolving landscape of commercial insurance, producers are constantly seeking ways to better connect with clients and prospects. While traditional sales techniques still hold value, the emergence of AI and a renewed focus on storytelling are reshaping how insurance producers approach their business. Storytelling is no longer just about features and benefits; it’s about addressing the internal struggles and emotions of customers. In this blog post, we’ll explore how commercial insurance producers can leverage AI-driven tools like StoryMaker to enhance storytelling, build trust, and ultimately drive sales.

Why Storytelling Matters in Sales

Storytelling as a Connection Tool

In a market flooded with insurance options, the ability to create an emotional connection with prospects is key. Storytelling allows producers to shift the focus away from products and policies and onto the customers themselves. Every insurance customer has a story, whether it’s the challenges of protecting their business from risk or the fear of experiencing a major financial loss. By telling compelling stories that highlight these internal struggles, producers can connect on a deeper level with their prospects and clients.

In the words of Jim Matuga, founder of Interaction Media, “Most people, when they talk about their business, focus on features and benefits, but what they miss is the problem they’re solving for the customer. The customer is the hero of the story, not you.”

When producers position their clients as the heroes of the story, they acknowledge that the client’s needs come first. This shift in perspective not only creates a more engaging narrative but also fosters trust between the producer and the client. Insurance isn’t just about policies—it’s about people. Storytelling allows producers to show they understand their clients’ concerns and are committed to helping them overcome their challenges.

The Customer as the Hero

A common mistake many insurance producers make is centering the conversation around their services, experience, and expertise. It’s crucial to focus on how your services solve a customer’s problems. When a producer makes the customer the hero, they put the spotlight on the customer’s journey, which in turn, builds rapport and trust.

Take the time to understand the internal and external problems your clients face. This not only makes your communication more effective but also positions you as a trusted advisor rather than just another salesperson.

Building Trust Through Empathy and Active Listening

Trust is the Foundation of Any Sales Relationship

In commercial insurance, trust is the foundation of long-lasting client relationships. Building trust doesn’t happen overnight—it’s a gradual process that requires empathy and consistent, effective communication. One of the best ways to build trust is to actively listen to your clients, ensuring you truly understand their needs before offering solutions.

David Carothers, host of the Power Producers podcast, highlights the importance of listening: “Sales is difficult because we make it difficult. If you just sit and listen, the person will give you the roadmap to how you get the deal done.”

By focusing on listening to understand rather than listening to respond, producers can uncover the deeper, internal issues their clients face. These issues often go beyond external risks like property damage or lawsuits. Listening attentively allows producers to address these deeper fears, which is where trust is built.

Showing Empathy

Empathy is another essential component of building trust. When a producer shows genuine concern for their client’s challenges, it signals that they care about more than just closing a deal—they care about the client’s overall well-being. Empathy is the bridge between understanding the client’s problems and presenting tailored solutions that truly meet their needs.

As Carothers points out in the podcast, empathy and trust go hand in hand. When clients feel heard and understood, they are more likely to trust the producer with their business. Producers who fail to express empathy risk coming across as self-serving, which can quickly erode trust and derail the sales process.

Using AI to Streamline Content Creation and Enhance Authenticity

How Generative AI is Changing the Sales Landscape

The sales landscape has changed dramatically with the introduction of generative AI tools like ChatGPT and StoryMaker. These tools offer insurance producers an efficient way to create high-quality, personalized content at scale. Whether it’s crafting emails, writing blog posts, or creating social media content, AI tools streamline the content creation process while ensuring that the final product maintains an authentic voice.

Jim Matuga’s company, Interaction Media, developed StoryMaker specifically to help producers and small businesses generate marketing content that resonates with their target audience. AI enables producers to efficiently create tailored content that solves prospects’ problems while preserving brand consistency.

Matuga explains, “StoryMaker was built to be an efficiency tool to help businesses create authentic content in their voice in a matter of seconds.”

AI tools like StoryMaker allow producers to focus more on building relationships with their clients rather than spending hours crafting content from scratch. In today’s fast-paced world, tools like StoryMaker help businesses save time and stay competitive.

The Balance Between Automation and Authenticity

While AI tools can automate much of the content creation process, it’s essential for producers to ensure that the final product is authentic. AI tools are only as effective as the guidance they receive. If AI content lacks the producer’s voice or misses audience concerns, it may create a disconnect with clients.

David Carothers offers a word of caution: “People mess up when they don’t train the language model in their voice. That creates a disconnect between you and the prospect when they talk to you after consuming your content.”

To avoid this, producers should take the time to teach AI tools how to write in their voice. This ensures that the content generated feels personal and resonates with the target audience. AI aids content creation, but producers must ensure the final product aligns with their messaging and brand identity.

AI as a Tool for Efficiency and Consistency

Scaling Your Marketing Efforts with AI

For producers looking to scale their marketing efforts, AI tools like StoryMaker provide a practical solution. Not only do these tools save time, but they also ensure that the content produced is consistent across different platforms. Whether you’re writing an email campaign, drafting a blog post, or creating social media content, AI can help maintain a unified tone and message that builds trust with your audience.

Consistency is key when it comes to content marketing. Clients expect a seamless experience when interacting with your brand, whether it’s through a blog post or a phone call. AI ensures that your messaging remains consistent, regardless of the platform or format.

Ensuring Consistency Across Platforms

Another benefit of AI tools is their ability to maintain a consistent voice across multiple touchpoints. For example, StoryMaker allows producers to store a library of previously created content, which can be reused and repurposed as needed. This is particularly useful for maintaining a consistent tone across marketing campaigns and ensuring that your messaging aligns with your overall brand.

As Matuga explains, “StoryMaker provides a repository of every piece of content you’ve ever created. This archive can be accessed and reused, ensuring consistency across all your marketing efforts.”

By using AI to ensure consistency, producers can build a stronger, more recognizable brand, which in turn fosters trust with their clients and prospects.

Real-World Applications and Success Stories

How AI Helped Commercial Producers Build Stronger Relationships

Producers who have embraced AI-driven tools have seen remarkable results. From saving time to generating more leads, AI has transformed the way producers interact with their clients. One real-world example comes from a producer who struggled with writing personalized emails and social media content. By using StoryMaker, this producer was able to generate engaging content quickly, allowing them to focus on building relationships with their clients.

Another success story involves a producer who used AI to craft more empathetic responses to client concerns. By leveraging AI to streamline email communication, the producer was able to respond more quickly to client needs, leading to stronger relationships and increased sales.

Lessons Learned from the Podcast

As discussed on the podcast, one of the biggest takeaways for producers is the importance of balancing automation with authenticity. While AI can significantly streamline the content creation process, producers must ensure that the content generated still reflects their unique voice and approach.

Bringing It All Together

The Future of AI and Storytelling in Sales

As AI continues to evolve, its role in the sales process will only become more prominent. For commercial insurance producers, AI offers a powerful way to create engaging, authentic content that resonates with clients and prospects. By combining the power of storytelling with the efficiency of AI, producers can build stronger relationships, establish trust, and drive sales.

A Call to Action

If you’re looking to enhance your content marketing efforts and build stronger connections with your clients, now is the time to explore AI-driven tools like StoryMaker. These tools not only save time but also ensure that your messaging is authentic and consistent across all platforms. Start using AI today to streamline your content creation process and take your sales strategy to the next level.

Maximizing Middle-Market Workers’ Compensation Success: Data-Driven Prospecting, Compliance Wedges, and Claims Excellence

July 31, 2025 No Comments

Middle-mazrket businesses face unique challenges when it comes to managing their workers’ compensation programs. Unlike large enterprises, they often lack dedicated in-house resources for safety, compliance, and claims oversight; yet unlike small businesses, their scale subjects them to more sophisticated regulatory scrutiny and larger potential losses. In this environment, commercial insurance producers who master an integrated approach—combining precise prospecting data, impactful compliance applications, and exceptional claims handling—can both win new accounts and build lasting client relationships.

Strategic Market Access for Independent Agencies: Unlocking Growth, Stability, and Profitability

July 31, 2025 No Comments

In the most challenging insurance market many of us have ever seen, independent agencies are grappling with a familiar foe: limited carrier access. Whether you’re a former captive agent trying to break into the independent space or a small agency trying to grow your commercial book, the obstacles are real. Direct appointments are hard to come by, especially for shops under $5 million in revenue, and wholesale markets can feel intimidating or like a last resort.

But they don’t have to be. With the right partner, wholesale and brokerage relationships can become a strategic advantage, not just a stopgap. This post explores how agencies can leverage smart market access to grow confidently, preserve profitability, and position themselves for long-term success.

Building High-Performing Remote Insurance Teams: Core Values, Hiring, Onboarding & KPI Strategies

July 30, 2025 No Comments

The insurance industry is undergoing a profound transformation as middle-market agencies recognize the benefits and challenges of embracing a fully remote workforce. No longer viewed as a temporary workaround, remote models offer the potential to tap into nationwide and offshore talent pools, reduce overhead, and increase flexibility in an increasingly digital world. Yet, flipping the switch to virtual operations can expose gaps in documentation, dilute corporate culture, and strain traditional oversight mechanisms. In this post, we’ll explore the four pillars essential to building a high-performing remote insurance team—core values, hiring practices, onboarding processes, and KPI strategies—while also delving into best practices for managing domestic versus offshore employees, ensuring data security, leveraging productivity tools, and fostering trust and autonomy.

Captive Insurance Strategies for Middle Market Success: Empowering Independent Agents with Risk Control and Profitability

July 28, 2025 No Comments

In today’s hard commercial insurance market, middle market business owners are more open than ever to solutions that give them greater control over their insurance costs. While guaranteed cost programs remain the default option, they often lack the flexibility and long-term savings that high-performing businesses crave. That’s where captive insurance comes in—a powerful but often misunderstood tool that enables clients to turn insurance from a sunk cost into a strategic asset.

Streamlining Agency Billing and Premium Financing: Leveraging FedNow, 3-D Secure, and Integrated AMS for Faster Funding

July 16, 2025 No Comments

Middle-market insurance agencies have long wrestled with the legacy “buy-bill-collect” model, in which carriers invoice agencies, agencies collect premiums from clients, and only then remit payment to carriers. This antiquated workflow creates operational friction, delayed cash flow, and elevated chargeback risks—all of which can erode profitability and client satisfaction. Today, however, powerful innovations in digital payments and agency management systems are enabling a modern “bill-collect-buy” paradigm that dramatically accelerates fund availability, minimizes disputes, and unlocks new revenue streams through premium financing.

Why Most Salespeople Fail: Mastering the Mindset, Process, and Power Dynamics of Professional Selling

July 8, 2025 No Comments

The truth about professional sales isn’t flashy, and it certainly isn’t about charisma. If you think selling is about having the “gift of gab,” winging it on calls, or leaning on your likability to win deals, you’re doing it wrong—and that’s why you’re struggling. In this post, we’re breaking down lessons from a brutally honest conversation with Benjamin Dennehy, the UK’s Most Hated Sales Trainer®, about why so many producers in commercial insurance and other industries fall short—and what the top performers do differently.