Protecting Your Best Accounts: Why Middle Market Producers Must Lead the Captive Conversation

Every producer has that account.

You know the one I’m talking about—the client whose premium check moves the needle from a good year to a great one. The one you’ve nurtured for years, who calls you on weekends, who brags about you to their peers.

Now picture this: Monday morning, the phone rings. It’s your top client.
“Hey, we need to talk. We’re going in a different direction.”

The six-figure revenue stream you counted on? Gone. Not because you didn’t return calls, drop by for lunch, or go the extra mile in service. They left because they needed something you didn’t have—and another producer put it on the table first.

That “something” was a captive.

Captives have been around for decades, but the game has changed. Once seen as the exclusive playground for massive corporations, captives are now a viable—and increasingly popular—option for middle market insurance accounts. If you’re not talking to your best clients about captives, rest assured: someone else is.

What Is a Captive and Why It Matters Now

A captive is a form of alternative risk financing where the insured essentially owns their own insurance company. Instead of “renting” coverage from a traditional carrier, they form or join a captive structure that allows them to:

Share risk with other like-minded businesses.
Gain greater transparency into premiums, claims, and loss performance.
Capture underwriting profits and investment income that would otherwise go to a carrier.
Build a long-term strategy to reduce total cost of risk.

For years, captives were associated with Fortune 500 budgets and massive premium volumes. But the captive landscape has evolved. Today, middle market accounts with as little as $250,000 in casualty premium (across general liability, auto, and workers’ comp) can often qualify.

That shift has opened the door for competitors to use captives as a wedge—and for proactive producers to use them as a client retention tool.

Why Accounts Really Leave

When Warren Cleveland from Captive Coalition joined me on Shop Talk, he shared a painful story.

He lost a $300,000 revenue client—not because of poor service, but because the client needed a captive option he wasn’t offering. They found it elsewhere.

Here’s the hard truth: good service is not enough.

Clients leave when you can’t solve their problem, and their problems are rarely about a late certificate or a slow claims response. They’re frustrated by:

Paying six or seven figures in premium with little transparency.
Claims that drag on or resolve unfavorably.
Year-after-year increases with no end in sight.

If a competitor offers them a path to control costs and gain transparency, they’ll take it—loyalty or no loyalty.

Identifying Captive Prospects in Your Book

Not every account is a good fit for a captive, but the signs aren’t hard to spot. Look for:

Premium Threshold – Generally, $250K+ in casualty premium (GL, auto, comp) makes the economics viable.
Growth Trajectory – Companies growing 20–30% per year will see compounded benefits from controlling their risk financing.
Risk Management Maturity – Solid safety programs, predictive loss history, and operational controls make a captive sustainable.
Near-Fit “Fringe” Accounts – Accounts just below the threshold but on track to hit it in the next year or two.

Producers often overlook those “fringe” accounts, but starting the captive conversation early allows you to position it as a long-term strategy rather than a last-minute pitch.

The Right Time to Start the Captive Conversation

Renewal season is the worst time to pitch a captive for the first time.

Here’s why: captives are a paradigm shift. You’re not talking about shopping the market—you’re talking about changing how they finance risk. That requires time, education, and internal buy-in.

The better approach? Build captive discussions into your ongoing client strategy:

Quarterly Claims Reviews – If loss ratios are improving, highlight how that performance could pay dividends in a captive.
Strategic Planning Meetings – When discussing next year’s goals, position a captive as part of the long-term vision.
Post-Renewal Debriefs – Use the calm after renewal to introduce the concept without the pressure of an immediate decision.

This keeps the conversation proactive and consultative, not defensive.

Expanding Your Geographic Footprint and Niche Reach

Captives aren’t just a retention play—they’re a growth strategy.

In traditional markets, producers can be limited by state-specific rating rules or carrier appetite. Captives offer more flexibility in structure and pricing, which can:

Open doors to accounts in other states without losing competitive position.
Allow niche specialists (HVAC, manufacturing, transportation, etc.) to build multi-state books.
Create a tighter value proposition for industries with predictable operations and loss patterns.

If you know your niche and can identify captive-ready accounts, your geographic location matters far less.

The Cost of Losing the Conversation

Here’s the danger: captive managers and large brokers are actively prospecting your best accounts.

And when a business owner gets frustrated enough to start Googling “captive insurance,” there are hundreds of ready, willing, and able providers eager to take the call. Many have internal producers who will gladly replace you in the process.

Even if they work with the client’s current agent sometimes, they won’t always bring you along.

The solution is simple—control the conversation before someone else does.

Making Captives Part of Your Agency’s Strategy

Here’s how to get started:

Audit Your Book – Identify every account above $250K casualty premium, plus fringe accounts close to qualifying.
Create a Captive Talking Points Guide – Keep the explanation simple, focusing on transparency, control, and long-term cost savings.
Educate Your Team – Producers and account managers should all be able to introduce the concept confidently.
Partner with the Right Captive Managers – Work with groups that collaborate rather than compete with producers.
Schedule Captive Reviews – Make captive viability a standard agenda item for high-value client strategy meetings.

Key Takeaways for Producers

Don’t wait until renewal to bring up captives.
You don’t have to be a captive expert—just know enough to open the door and connect the right resources.
Proactively identify and approach captive-ready accounts before your competitors do.
Build captive exploration into your standard client engagement process.

Conclusion – Stay Ahead or Get Replaced

The middle market is shifting. Captives are no longer a niche solution—they’re a mainstream risk financing strategy. That means your competitors are using them as a wedge to win your best accounts.

You have two choices:

Keep doing what you’ve always done and hope loyalty is enough.
Become the producer who brings every viable solution—including captives—to the table before anyone else does.

If you choose the second, you’re not just protecting your book—you’re solidifying your position as a strategic advisor in the eyes of your clients.

And in today’s market, that’s the only position worth having.

Service Over Sales: How Hospitality Principles Create Better Insurance Producers

November 12, 2025 No Comments

That idea sits at the heart of a powerful conversation I had with Joe Hollier, better known as Mr. Hotel, on the Power Producers Podcast. Joe’s story is one that every producer can learn from. He started his career in hospitality, spent two decades working in restaurants and hotels, and eventually found his way into insurance. What he brought with him from hospitality turned out to be his biggest competitive advantage — the ability to understand people.

From Fax Blasts to Trusted Advisors: Timeless Sales Strategies That Still Win Today

November 10, 2025 No Comments

In the fast-paced world of commercial insurance, new trends and technologies seem to emerge daily. But some strategies stand the test of time—particularly when they’re rooted in deep client empathy, practical experience, and a commitment to legacy. In this post, we reflect on insights shared by Kevin Ring from the Institute of WorkComp Professionals during a recent Power Producers Podcast. Kevin joined David Carothers to honor the contributions of industry legend Preston Diamond and explore how his wisdom still applies in today’s sales landscape.

Authenticity, Hustle, and Humor: Redefining Success for the Modern Insurance Producer

October 30, 2025 No Comments

The insurance industry isn’t known for flash or flair. Most people picture gray suits, paperwork, and words like “renewal,” “loss runs,” or “premium audit.” But a new generation of producers is proving that this business doesn’t have to be boring. They’re showing that authenticity, energy, and creativity can make insurance not only engaging but a platform for meaningful connection and career fulfillment.

Producers vs Processors: How Young Talent, Fee-Based Models, and Transparency Are Disrupting Commercial Insurance

October 30, 2025 No Comments

The world of commercial insurance is evolving rapidly. It’s no longer just about quoting policies and hoping for renewals. Today, producers have the opportunity to lead with value, bring strategy to the sales process, and create long-lasting client relationships that transcend policy pricing.

Marketing Intelligence for Insurance Agencies: Tracking, Attribution, and Data-Driven Growth

October 20, 2025 No Comments

In the ever-evolving world of commercial insurance, marketing has become a critical lever for growth. Yet most agencies still struggle to understand what’s actually working. From websites that generate leads with no attribution to CRM systems that silo vital data, insurance agencies are often flying blind.

How Data-Driven Prospecting and CRM Tools Are Reshaping Middle Market Commercial Insurance Sales