Why Most Insurance Producers Fail in the Middle Market

Fixing Mindset, Structure, and Prospecting Strategy to Build a Book That Lasts

The commercial insurance landscape is evolving rapidly. As the market hardens and technology disrupts traditional models, more and more producers and agency owners are turning away from personal lines and small commercial accounts in pursuit of larger, more strategic middle market opportunities. The shift is logical—middle market clients offer better revenue, deeper relationships, and more room to make an impact.

But despite the potential, many producers fall short. It’s not because they aren’t talented, motivated, or eager to grow. It’s because they approach middle market the wrong way. They treat it like a scaled-up version of small business insurance. In reality, it’s a completely different world—with different buyers, different expectations, and a dramatically different sales cycle.

If you want to succeed in the middle market, you have to rewire how you think, plan, and execute. This post will show you how.

Thinking Like a Business Owner, Not Just an Employee

Middle market success starts with treating your book of business like a business. That means tracking your profit and loss, understanding the value of your time, and focusing on return-on-investment in everything you do. You’re not just a salesperson—you’re an entrepreneur operating inside the walls of an agency.

This mindset shift is especially important when you face pressure—from owners, carriers, wholesalers—to produce quickly. When you operate with long-term strategy and intentional execution, you protect your time and energy from being wasted on unqualified or misaligned accounts.

Defining the Middle Market and Its Buyer Personas

Ask five producers what “middle market” means, and you’ll likely get five different answers. But for practical purposes, we define middle market as accounts with $25,000 to $500,000+ in total premium. That’s a wide band, so let’s break it down into three segments.

$25K–$100K: The Transactional Segment

This is where things still feel like small commercial. These clients are typically price-driven, skeptical of process, and quick to shop around. You’re often dealing with the owner, the spouse, or someone who handles insurance because nobody else wants to.

$100K–$250K: The Consultative Middle

At this level, you’re often working with office managers or controllers. These buyers are more open to hearing about risk management, HR resources, and claims process improvements. You can start differentiating by solving operational problems.

$250K and Up: The Strategic Buyer

This is where you meet with CFOs, VPs of Finance, and seasoned executives. They often understand the mechanics of insurance and are open to strategic planning. Conversations here are deeper, more structured, and longer term.

Understanding these tiers is crucial. The strategies that work at one level can be disastrous at another. You must adapt your sales conversations to match the buyer’s sophistication.

The Six Internal Enemies of Producers

Most producers don’t fail because they lack talent. They fail because they let one (or more) of these internal enemies go unchecked.

Lack of Focus

Trying to be everything to everyone is a guaranteed way to go nowhere. Define your ideal prospect profile. Stick to it. If you deviate, it should be strategic—not reactive.

Imposter Syndrome

You belong in the room. If the prospect agreed to meet with you, they’ve already validated your presence. Confidence comes from preparation and consistency. You don’t have to be the expert on everything—you just have to be a trusted guide who brings value.

Fear of Rejection

Detach from the outcome. Focus on the present. Rejection is a natural part of the sales process. If you’re not hearing “no” enough, you’re probably not doing enough outreach.

Lack of Structure

Calendar management and time blocking are the unsung heroes of sales success. Whether you use a CRM, spreadsheet, or legal pad—track everything. Know your drop-to-appointment ratio. Know your conversion rates.

No Clear Why

Your purpose matters. Whether it’s family, faith, financial independence, or helping companies become safer and more profitable—your why will carry you when discipline falters.

Excuse Making

Excuses are common. Accountability is rare. The producers who consistently win don’t look for reasons why they couldn’t—they look for ways they can.

Planning for Consistency and Execution

Calendar Management and Time Blocking

If it’s not on your calendar, it doesn’t exist. Block time for:

Marketing drops
Follow-ups
Email outreach
Proposal development
Client education
Strategy sessions

Treat your calendar like a teleprompter. Follow it to the letter. This discipline eliminates decision fatigue and allows your momentum to build over time.

Build Systems Around Your Lead-In Strategy

What’s your wedge? Workers’ comp? OSHA compliance? Certificate turnaround time? Audit prep?

Whatever it is, build a system around it. Create downloadable tools. Offer value before the sale. Let that value carry your conversations deeper than price ever could.

Defining and Sticking to Your Ideal Prospect Profile

It’s tempting to chase shiny objects, especially when revenue pressure is high. But that’s how you end up wasting time and energy on accounts that never convert—or worse, become clients that drain your capacity.

Build your ideal prospect profile around:

Industry verticals
Size of business
Revenue or premium thresholds
Cultural alignment
Appetite of your carriers

Then hold yourself accountable. If an opportunity doesn’t fit the box, walk away. As David said in the session, “There’s no size limit to an account being screwed up.” Discipline protects you from bad business.

Leading with Value, Not Just Coverage

The best producers solve problems. Anyone can get a deck page and a quote. That’s not a value proposition—it’s a commodity.

Instead, offer:

Risk assessments
Loss control plans
Safety training
Audit and mod analysis
Online certificate management
OSHA hazard communication reviews

Build industry-specific positioning using your own experience. If you used to work in a restaurant, you already know where the risk lives in the kitchen. If you were in construction, speak that language. Value lives in context.

Mind, Body, and Spirit: The Producer’s Competitive Advantage

Sales is a demanding profession. Burnout is real. So is drift.

To stay sharp, you need to align your mind, body, and spirit:

Exercise regularly—even 20 minutes can make a difference
Journal or reflect to keep your mind clear
Meditate, pray, or follow whatever keeps you centered

Producers who operate at peak performance do so because they design their days with intention. This is your edge. Use it.

Conclusion: It’s a Marathon, Not a Sprint

Middle market production isn’t about quick wins. It’s about compounding consistency. Once your flywheel is spinning, it gets easier—but starting is the hardest part.

Remember:

Don’t let rejection derail you
Don’t chase what’s not a fit
Don’t confuse activity with productivity
And never compromise your values for a sale

There’s always another account. There’s never another first impression. As David shared in the session: “You can’t out-earn your mindset.” Start there—and success will follow.

Service Over Sales: How Hospitality Principles Create Better Insurance Producers

November 12, 2025 No Comments

That idea sits at the heart of a powerful conversation I had with Joe Hollier, better known as Mr. Hotel, on the Power Producers Podcast. Joe’s story is one that every producer can learn from. He started his career in hospitality, spent two decades working in restaurants and hotels, and eventually found his way into insurance. What he brought with him from hospitality turned out to be his biggest competitive advantage — the ability to understand people.

From Fax Blasts to Trusted Advisors: Timeless Sales Strategies That Still Win Today

November 10, 2025 No Comments

In the fast-paced world of commercial insurance, new trends and technologies seem to emerge daily. But some strategies stand the test of time—particularly when they’re rooted in deep client empathy, practical experience, and a commitment to legacy. In this post, we reflect on insights shared by Kevin Ring from the Institute of WorkComp Professionals during a recent Power Producers Podcast. Kevin joined David Carothers to honor the contributions of industry legend Preston Diamond and explore how his wisdom still applies in today’s sales landscape.

Authenticity, Hustle, and Humor: Redefining Success for the Modern Insurance Producer

October 30, 2025 No Comments

The insurance industry isn’t known for flash or flair. Most people picture gray suits, paperwork, and words like “renewal,” “loss runs,” or “premium audit.” But a new generation of producers is proving that this business doesn’t have to be boring. They’re showing that authenticity, energy, and creativity can make insurance not only engaging but a platform for meaningful connection and career fulfillment.

Producers vs Processors: How Young Talent, Fee-Based Models, and Transparency Are Disrupting Commercial Insurance

October 30, 2025 No Comments

The world of commercial insurance is evolving rapidly. It’s no longer just about quoting policies and hoping for renewals. Today, producers have the opportunity to lead with value, bring strategy to the sales process, and create long-lasting client relationships that transcend policy pricing.

Marketing Intelligence for Insurance Agencies: Tracking, Attribution, and Data-Driven Growth

October 20, 2025 No Comments

In the ever-evolving world of commercial insurance, marketing has become a critical lever for growth. Yet most agencies still struggle to understand what’s actually working. From websites that generate leads with no attribution to CRM systems that silo vital data, insurance agencies are often flying blind.

How Data-Driven Prospecting and CRM Tools Are Reshaping Middle Market Commercial Insurance Sales